From the Editor: Archives
The pronunciation of placenames
Feb 10, 2016
The pronunciation of placenames can cause great difficulty. It is easy to spot an outsider by the mistakes that they make, usually a cause for mirth or irritation for the locals. There is no solution to this except to check with the locals, because names can come from a variety of sources and undergo considerable change.
English placenames in Australia tend to follow the established patterns of placenames in the UK, so we learn that Leicester is not /lee-sess-tuh/ or some such three-syllable variation, but /less-tuh/, and that Marlborough is not /marl-buh-ruh/ but /marl-bruh/, and Chiswick is not /chiz-wik/ but /chiz-uhk/.
But it is not all smooth sailing. In the UK, Derby is pronounced /dar-bee/, but our WA coastal town is most definitely /der-bee/. Jervis is pronounced /jar-vuhs/ in the UK, and so Jervis Bay on the southern NSW coast was pronounced /jar-vuhs/ by Sydneysiders who thought they knew the English pattern. The locals said /jer-vuhs/ but this was disregarded as ignorance. The Bay had been named after Admiral John Jervis, 1735-1823, so one of the locals contacted his descendants who said that, while it was true that in the UK Jervis was mostly pronounced /jar-vuhs/, his branch of the family pronounced it /jer-vuhs/. Therefore /jer-vuhs/ for Jervis Bay was correct.
There has been a fashion in more recent times for reviewing established pronunciations of placenames to bring them into line with the pronunciation that they would have in the language from which they came. So there was an attempt to change the pronunciation of Kosciuszko from /ko-zee-oss-koh/ to /kuh-shoos-koh/. We are now attempting to say /chil-lay/ rather than /chil-ee/ for Chile. If we were determined to see this through we would talk about /puh-ree/ rather than /pa-ruhs/. Possibly the /puh-ree/ pronunciation is associated with ‘gay Paris’ and popular songs, and doesn’t seem serious enough.
In Australia we have to deal with a large number of placenames from Aboriginal languages. Sometimes these names have been Anglicised, sometimes there is an attempt to capture something of the original sounds and stress patterns.
In my innocent youth I had the impression that one place would have one name which would have one pronunciation which would endure over time. I have come to realise that placenames are fluid, evolving, varied, playthings of history, in short, a minefield.
It becomes a matter of language etiquette. Just as you would draw aside the guest speaker at a dinner and establish the correct pronunciation of their somewhat indecipherable name, so you have to check with the locals what the established pronunciation is for their town. On the odd occasion there is no time for this, and we just have to hope that the locals forgive us.
(Image courtesy of Bäras~commonswiki, Wikimedia Commons, CC 3.0)